End Comments

Here are the guidelines for completing a peer review.

1st: Read the paper once to get an impression of the work
2nd: Read it again, this time with a pen and mark your suggestions/corrections to the work. Be sure to give advice, not criticism.

3rd: Write end comments.
I. I a letter to the author detail:
A. Three to four positive comments, specifically detailing what the author is doing that you find effective. No "I thought it was good." Yes: "The scene when your father comes home really slows down and describes the narrative action effectively. This helped build the suspense of the story."
B. Three to four suggestions (not criticisms) to the author that reflect your ideas for how the essay can be more effective. Use pages 58-59 as a reference since that is what I will use to grade the essays.